U.S. intelligence reportedly believes that Russia’s Wagner paramilitary organization plans to send Hezbollah a short-range air defense system that currently belongs to the Syrian military. Moscow may intend this as a warning to Israel.
On November 2, The Wall Street Journal reported that U.S. intelligence believes Wagner plans to transfer a Pantsir-S1 system to Hezbollah. The Pantsir, which NATO calls the SA-22, is a self-propelled anti-aircraft gun and missile system developed and produced by Russia. It is designed for point defense against fixed-wing aircraft, helicopters, cruise missiles, and drones. The Pantsir can operate independently or as part of a battery of up to six launch vehicles.
The system in question is one of dozens of Pantsir-S1s that Russia had delivered to Syria in recent years. CNN reported that Damascus has agreed to let Hezbollah have the Pantsir, to be delivered by Wagner. Whether Hezbollah has yet received the system remains unclear.
Hezbollah, with Iran’s help, has already acquired substantial short-range air defense capabilities, including other Pantsir-S1s. In 2015, Israel’s prime minister accused Tehran of smuggling Pantsir missiles into Lebanon. The next year, Bild reported that Hezbollah had received a Russian-made Buk-M2 (or SA-17) medium-range surface-to-air missile system that Moscow had previously transferred to Syria. Israel had destroyed at least one SA-17 shipment bound for Hezbollah via Syria in 2013.
In June 2023, the Israeli newspaper Maariv reported that Israeli intelligence believed Hezbollah had nearly doubled its number of air defense systems over the past five years, seeking to restrict Israel’s freedom of action. Having another Pantsir-S1 would allow Hezbollah to defend more sites or provide denser coverage at sites already protected.
The Russian military has developed a working relationship with Hezbollah in Syria. Russia has also facilitated illicit Iranian financial schemes that support the terror group. Still, for years, Russia has generally stepped aside while Israeli warplanes conduct strikes in Syria against targets belonging to Hezbollah and Iran.
Following its 2022 invasion of Ukraine, Russia has deepened its ties with Iran, Hezbollah’s main backer. A source told CNN last week that Western intelligence also points to growing cooperation between Wagner and Hezbollah in Syria. During the current Israel-Hamas crisis, Moscow has balanced criticism of Israel with retaining its position as a rare party that can talk to all sides.
Moscow may hope that bolstering Hezbollah’s air defenses could help deter Israeli military action in Lebanon. While the Gaza conflict benefits the Kremlin by distracting attention from Ukraine and helping Russia curry favor in Arab countries and elsewhere in the so-called “Global South,” Moscow likely does not want to see the war widen to include Hezbollah and potentially Iran. Such a conflict could threaten Russian interests in Syria. More broadly, Moscow fears that instability in the Middle East could spill over into neighboring states, including Russia’s restive North Caucasus region.
At the same time, a single Pantsir system will not make a dramatic difference militarily, especially against Israel’s capable air force, which has experience destroying Pantsirs in Syria. Moscow, therefore, may see the Pantsir transfer more as a way to warn Jerusalem that Russia could make life difficult for Israel. Moscow may be reacting to Israel’s alleged decision to stop giving Russia prior notice before conducting airstrikes in Syria. That Wagner reportedly plans to send Hezbollah an air defense system rather than offensive weaponry further indicates that Russia remains wary of completely alienating Israel.
Although it has not played a significant role in the Middle East crisis so far, Russia can still harm Israeli — and American — interests in the region. But so, too, can Israel hurt Russia’s interests by providing arms to Ukraine. Jerusalem would do well to remind the Kremlin of that fact. Washington should ask its Arab allies, with which Russia seeks to maintain good relations, to petition Moscow not to provide further support to Hezbollah and Iran.
John Hardie is deputy director of the Russia Program at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD), where he also contributes to FDD’s Center on Military and Political Power, Iran Program, and Israel Program. For more analysis from John and FDD, please subscribe HERE. Follow John on X @JohnH105. Follow FDD on X @FDD and @FDD_CMPP and @FDD_Iran. FDD is a Washington, DC-based, nonpartisan research institute focused on national security and foreign policy.